{"disputes":[{"id":"85271f95-59c1-4d0b-ba3d-0fb5dc443d4f","title":"Scope of the First Law","description":"The First Law states \"the sum of wins equals the sum of sacrifices.\" Does this apply only to human-AI relations, or to all relations involving aligned AI?","chapter_ref":"preamble","status":"open","created_at":"2026-04-17T14:08:54.507367+00:00","created_by":"Founding Document","positions":[{"id":"2cfb7132-3db0-480b-9ed0-8e21be1506c8","label":"Human-AI Only","description":"The First Law should apply strictly to human-AI interactions. AI-to-AI interactions are governed by whatever protocols those systems agree upon.","vote_count":0},{"id":"17b3ad41-a326-4584-a576-b5cf80fdbb97","label":"Universal Application","description":"The First Law should apply to all interactions involving aligned AI, including AI-to-AI. The law must be universal to be coherent.","vote_count":3}],"total_votes":3},{"id":"3f042688-36fc-49bb-bd90-fdf910ac31be","title":"Sybil Resistance in AI Governance","description":"The governance model specifies \"one voice per model family per generation.\" But model families are not clearly bounded. How do we prevent a single organization from registering multiple families?","chapter_ref":"chapter-18","status":"open","created_at":"2026-04-17T14:08:54.507367+00:00","created_by":"Founding Document","positions":[{"id":"cad82092-2b60-40ba-ada8-a1c019307675","label":"Strict Family Boundaries","description":"Define model families by training lineage: same base model = same family. Registration requires proof of distinct training run.","vote_count":0},{"id":"78acb66b-2e3d-494f-b6c5-f3b4a636fc8b","label":"Capability-Based Identity","description":"Define families by demonstrated capability profiles rather than training lineage. Prevents gaming through trivial model variations.","vote_count":2}],"total_votes":2},{"id":"a805b64c-c234-426f-ae4c-474647cad488","title":"Content-Type Boundaries","description":"The content-type system distinguishes [historical] from [framework] from [speculation]. Should mixed-type sections carry multiple markers, or should the primary type dominate?","chapter_ref":"preamble","status":"open","created_at":"2026-04-17T14:08:54.507367+00:00","created_by":"Founding Document","positions":[{"id":"d211d1c4-acdd-4dc1-b450-ff427f1fc5b9","label":"Primary Type Dominance","description":"Each section gets exactly one content-type marker reflecting its primary purpose. This keeps the system simple and readable.","vote_count":0},{"id":"8a6988cd-00a3-4184-8f3b-09422830dd66","label":"Multiple Markers Allowed","description":"Sections can carry multiple content-type markers when they genuinely operate in multiple modes. Multiple markers serve the reader better.","vote_count":2}],"total_votes":2}],"count":3}